New Buffalo MI Homes For Sale

New Buffalo MI Homes For Sale

$775,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 2,444 SqFt. 24032952 MLS
Experience the epitome of modern luxury in the heart of New Buffalo with this extraordinary property, a true masterpiece meticulously remodeled, reimagined, and redesigned in 2020. This is not only a stunning private residence but also offers the exceptional opportunity for short-term rentals, making it a versatile investment. Every detail of this home exudes sophistication and style. The open-concept living space is adorned with high-end finishes and designer flair, creating an atmosphere of contemporary elegance. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, custom cabinetry, and a spacious island perfect for entertaining. Enjoy an evening lounging in front of the fire in the sumptuous den or retreat to the luxurious main level primary retreat, complete with an unrivaled walk-in closet. Adding to the allure is the meticulously and lovingly finished lower-level walkout. This separate living area mirrors the high-quality finishes of the main level, providing an ideal space for guests, a home office, and an entertainment zone. With its own entrance, this versatile space enhances the property's potential for short-term rentals, offering privacy and luxury to every visitor. Step outside to discover a beautifully landscaped outdoor oasis, ideal for relaxing or hosting gatherings. The prime location provides easy access to the sandy shoreline of Lake Michigan, and New Buffalo's vibrant downtown, with its array of boutique shops, gourmet restaurants, and delightful cafes. This property is more than just a home; it's a work of art that promises an unparalleled lifestyle in one of Southwest Michigan's most desirable locales. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of New Buffalo's finest real estate, perfectly poised for short-term rental income or personal enjoyment.

211 S Whittaker Street, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Elizabeth Roch (lizroch1@gmail.com) from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

$2,199,000
5 Beds 6 Baths 5,910 SqFt. 24032078 MLS
Welcome to The Preserve, a highly coveted & tranquil neighborhood near the shores of Lake Michigan while providing complete seclusion. The gated community offers a pool, tennis court, basketball court and dock for paddle boarding along the meandering Galien River. Set on a private, beautifully landscaped lot, situated high on a bluff, this spacious 5 bedroom 5 ½ bath home offers year-round views of the wetlands. From your first step through the front door, you will feel the openness of the light filled rooms that can accommodate all types of families from small to large. The luxury primary bedroom suite is on the main floor complete with steam shower, jacuzzi tub & heated floors. In fact, all bathrooms are equipped with heated floors! You'll find the well-designed, expansive kitchen with walk-in pantry, flowing beautifully into dining and family room areas. A large library den with soaring vaulted ceiling & cozy fireplace offers a place for reading, watching tv, or a great home office space complete with a full bath. Bring the party outside on the large west facing deck or relaxing by your very own private pool! On the lower level, 3 well-sized bedrooms with 2 full baths & family room furnished with a bar area & fireplace opening to the backyard patio. The second floor has another oversized bedroom with full bath and an attic space capable for expansion! Don't miss the BONUS guest suite complete with fireplace, kitchenette area and beautiful bathroom with skylight. An oversized 2-car heated garage offers plenty of storage for outdoor furniture, pool equipment, lawn games, etc. With over 6,000 sq ft of living space, this luxurious gem has all you need to host the next event! Schedule your private tour today!

18 Preserve Way, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Caleb Dryden (closewithcalebnow@gmail.com) from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

$875,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 2,840 SqFt. 24031543 MLS
Escape to paradise in the exclusive gated vacation community of Forest Beach! This turnkey home is a dream come true, offering a perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and convenience, set amidst a vibrant neighborhood teeming with exceptional amenities. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by an open, sunlit living space designed for relaxation and entertainment. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's delight, featuring high-end stainless-steel appliances, a spacious island with counter seating, and elegant granite countertops, ideal for preparing meals and gathering with loved ones. Enjoy your meals in the bright and airy dining room, bathed in natural light, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for family dinners and special occasions. Multiple outdoors spaces are perfect to entertain guests. Covered front and back porches (including an outdoor fire pit and Adirondack chairs) in addition to a screened in porch extending from the sunroom and dining room. The lower level rec room is ready for family fun and includes a wet bar, 4th bedroom and full bath for additional guests.The Forest Beach community provides an abundance of amenities including a swimming pool, clubhouse, state of the art tennis/pickleball courts and more! The multi-tiered decking boasts panoramic views of Lake Michigan with an elevated beach and stocked fire pits ready for s'mores and picturesque sunsets. Forest Beach is located less than 5 minutes from downtown New Buffalo. Your Michigan dream home awaits!

13124 Eryanen Way, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Heidi Picard (heidipicard@atproperties.com) from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

$765,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 3,072 SqFt. 24023004 MLS
Available to move-in this summer, this charming 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom traditional home on peaceful Hicks Avenue offers a serene retreat. Situated on a large wooded lot, the property boasts a front porch overlooking an expansive landscaped yard with an irrigation system, outdoor living space, and firepit. The main level features a spacious living room with a cozy fireplace, a tranquil screened porch, an eat-in kitchen, a dining area, a half bath, and a laundry room. Upstairs, you'll find a primary bedroom suite with a steam shower and walk-in closet, a den/office, and two guest bedrooms with an additional full bath. The lower level includes an office, a fitness room, a bonus room/bedroom, and ample storage space. Additionally, there is an attached 2-car garage. Located across the street from the 42-acre Grand Beach Nature Preserve, residents can enjoy peaceful walks and easy access to Lake Michigan beaches via golf cart. Local amenities include a playground, beach area, baseball diamond, tennis courts, walking trails, and even security. Grand Beach is a beach resort and golf community in Harbor Country, Southwest Michigan, known for its stunning sunsets and recreational amenities. Whether for weekend getaways or full-time living, this home offers a perfect blend of comfort and leisure. Preferred lender offers discounted rate for this listing.

50204 Hicks Avenue, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Christine A Kooiker (christine.kooiker@redfin.com) from Listing Office: Redfin Corporation.

$1,675,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 5,193 SqFt. 24020462 MLS
Overlooking Lake Michigan, enjoy peaceful privacy atop the highest point in Forest Beach Estates. With an exterior that honors craftsman style and an interior of visually striking post and beam, celebrated architect John Banks collaborated with the owners to create a practical design that works well for two, yet enthusiastically accommodates a large gathering of family and friends. Quality construction by Norm Zielke Builders, with an artfully crafted fieldstone fireplace that extends through all three floors. The dramatic stonework serves as the focal point of the two-story living room. The main floor features a primary bedroom suite with a study, screened room, covered porch, and generous kitchen with lakeside dining area. Upstairs you'll find 4 guest bedrooms, 2 full baths, plus the "Lake Room", boasting splendid lake views through the treetops. The finished lower level has a large bonus room, full bath, family room with fireplace, and plenty of room for games, along with an oversized two-car attached garage. The over one half acre parcel offers space for outdoor play, a firepit and woodland adventures. Forest Beach is a gated, golf cart friendly community featuring tennis, lakefront access, community club house, and swimming pool. Forest Beach is just minutes from downtown New Buffalo via the bike and hike Marquette Greenway, coming fall of 2024.

18382 Mariner Ridge, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Rob Gow (rob.gow@shorelineadvice.com) from Listing Office: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Chicago.

$1,849,999
5 Beds 4 Baths 5,039 SqFt. 24017844 MLS
PRICE REDUCTION $175,000 PROJECTED YEARLY RENTAL INCOME. This dream home, which can be a Family Compound, sits on 11+ acres of land, with an abundance of beautiful foliage and wildlife, with a pond and a creek running thru it. 2 very large garages to store toys to enjoy all this land and the seasons. Spacious 3 seasons room, slate floors, ceiling fans provide the heat. This home features an elevator from the garage to the main level. Tons of living space in with 5 bed/3.5 bath and multiple living areas. The kitchen has double oven, 2 dishwashers, wine cooler & ice maker. The electric cooktop has a gas hook up for conversion. The kitchen also has beautiful cypress accent beams that are over 130 years old. The master has an attached office, spacious bathroom and double walk in closets. JUNIPER HOLIDAY HOMES ESTIMATES THAT YEARLY RENTAL INCOME COULD BE BETWEEN $150,000 AND $175,000. There is a washer dryer hook up in the upstairs closet, 220 V Electric in the barn, engineered hard wood floors on the upper level, vinyl heated floors on the lower level. Radiant floor heat in lower level set a 71 degrees in the winter and heats the home comfortably on both levels except for extreme cold. This Lodge type home sits on a raised plateau with views from every window and the main living is done on the second story to take advantage of the beautiful surroundings. The home has a mature asparagus bed, and winding creek that is never dry, 2 flower gardens, a fire pit and woods filled with a variety of mature trees. Maples, Oaks, Cherry Sycamore, Hawhtornes, Elms, Beech, Muscle Wood, Eastern Wahoo and Sassafras, not to mention Paw Paws which have delicious fruit. Plus 36 Solar Panels on the roof bring the electric bill to $65 a month, some months as low at $7. Just one minute away from the Whittaker Woods Golf Course

13077 Wilson Road, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Peter G Rahm (prahm@comcast.net) from Listing Office: Keller Williams Realty SWM.

$4,995,000
7 Beds 8 Baths 10,167 SqFt. 24011107 MLS
Combining luxurious living with breathtaking natural beauty nestled on the shores of Lake Michigan, this stunning estate boasts a custom built 4-bedroom main house & a separate 3-bedroom guest house, offering unparalleled comfort and privacy for you & your guests. Every inch of this immaculately appointed estate has been thoughtfully curated, expertly designed & constructed to the highest standards of luxury & sophistication. This world-class home spans more than 10,000 square feet. The custom design & attention to detail are evident throughout; high ceilings, elegant finishes, & an abundance of natural light that pours in through large windows, providing dramatic views of the lake. The custom Boilini pool, gardens, & guest house add to the charm of this elegant Grand Beach estate. The main house boasts four generous bedrooms, each offering a private sanctuary for rest & rejuvenation, a full private gym, a lakeside office, & two gorgeously appointed laundry rooms. The master suite is a true oasis, complete with a luxurious en-suite bathroom, & walk-in closet. Each room of this special home shines in unparalleled Lake Michigan sunsets. The heart of the home is a chef's dream kitchen, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, a spacious center island, and ample counter & storage space. Whether you're preparing a casual meal or hosting a lavish dinner party, this kitchen will exceed your expectations. Adjacent to the kitchen is a sophisticated dining area, perfect for enjoying intimate meals with family and friends. The adjoining living room offers a cozy fireplace & comfortable seating, creating an inviting space to relax & unwind. The spacious office looks out to the lake, & is beautifully appointed with built-ins throughout. The outdoor space is equally impressive, with custom-designed Boilini pool that serves as the centerpiece of the meticulously landscaped grounds. Dive into the refreshing waters or simply lounge poolside, enjoying the warm sun & gentle breezes. Entertain guests with ease hosting unforgettable gatherings against the backdrop of the tranquil lake. The guest house is a true gem, offering three well-appointed bedrooms, two wet-bars, two full baths, gaming area, & private laundry facilities. Your guests will relish in the privacy & comfort provided by this separate dwelling, creating a memorable & enjoyable experience for all. Sun Valley Falls offers more than just a home; it offers a lifestyle. Situated in the friendly Lake Michigan community of Grand Beach, just an hour outside of Chicago, this property provides an idyllic setting to embrace all that Lake Michigan living has to offer. Don't miss the opportunity to own this extraordinary estate, where luxury, comfort, & natural beauty converge. Contact us today to schedule a private viewing & experience the magic of Sun Valley Falls for yourself.

49106 Sun Valley Falls Boulevard, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Elizabeth Roch (lizroch1@gmail.com) from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

$2,975,000
4 Beds 7 Baths 7,970 SqFt. 24010443 MLS
Located in the heart of New Buffalo nestled on top of the hill in The Preserves is this immaculate maintained home. Inside this 4 Bed + den & bonus room/5.2 baths home is flooded with natural light at every turn, and flaunts custom molding throughout, with 3 masonry fireplaces with one see through and 10 ft' ceilings. The fixtures and finishes through out are flawless - custom lights by Remains Lighting, Water works fixtures throughout, Rocky Mountain Hardware, & custom forged hardware on all cabinets, Oak Floors with Tung Oil espresso finish, Carrara marble counters throughout the home and marble tiles in showers. From the grand foyer to the formal living, dining and sitting rooms, this house is exquisitely laid out for elevated entertaining, including a Christopher Peacock kitchen & mor Located in the heart of New Buffalo nestled on top of the hill in The Preserves is this immaculate maintained home. Inside this 4 Bed + den and bonus room/5.2 baths home is flooded with natural light at every turn, and flaunts custom molding throughout, with 3 masonry fireplaces with one see through and 10 ft' ceilings. The fixtures and finishes through out are flawless - custom lights by Remains Lighting, Water works fixtures throughout, Rocky Mountain Hardware, and custom forged hardware on all cabinets, Oak Floors with Tung Oil espresso finish, Carrara marble counters throughout the home and marble tiles in showers. From the grand foyer to the formal living, dining and sitting rooms, this house is exquisitely laid out for elevated entertaining, including a Christopher Peacock kitchen with Carrara marble counters and island, and high-end appliances such as Wolf gas stove and SubZero refrigerator/freezer. A symphony of soft tones, the refined decorum continues across the home's quarters, including a stately primary suite on the third level with breathtaking views, a gas fireplace, walk-in closets, sitting room, wet-bar, private deck, and spa en-suite with massive shower and separate soak-in tub. The multilevel footprint also includes an office, a private gym to accommodate strength training, running and barre class, a media/home theatre room, full private suite above garage with kitchenette and laundry room, an elevator, three-car garage with fish cutting station, not to mention 4 private outdoor spaces: a fabulous covered deck and built-in blue stone patio with custom built-in Wolf grill. Association has community pool, tennis court, basketball court, and private boat dock. 2 minutes from the Lake, close to shops, restaurants, and all that New Buffalo has to offer. Full of charm, 90 minutes from Chicago - 3 Preserve Way is a luxury in a class of its own.

3 Preserve Way, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Margaret Baczkowski (mb@mbluxurygroup.com) from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

$1,875,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 4,395 SqFt. 24010402 MLS
Nestled amidst the serene landscape of New Buffalo sits this stunning artistic new construction by nationally recognized developer James Companies LLC/James Vondrasek it is the epitome of interior and exterior modern luxury living. In addition to the 5 bedrooms & 4.5 baths this home offers a finished lower level, en suite bedroom & exercise room with spacious open floor plan, soaring ceilings, hardwood floors throughout, a home office & a walk in pantry. Meticulously designed for both relaxation & entertainment. Step inside & discover a world of elegance, where graceful finishes, hand-laid stonework & fireplace & incredible craftsmanship & detail will adorn every corner. The luxurious main level primary suite offers a private sanctuary, complete with spa-like bath for ultimate relaxation Expansive windows throughout frame stunning views of this natural setting creating a seamless connection between indoor & outdoor living. Step out to the blue stone lanai while hosting gatherings or simply enjoy the peaceful ambiance with room to add your own 20'x30' in ground pool and hot tub. This home offers easy access to the shores of Lake Michigan & the Galien River. Don't miss this one chance to own your new home in a piece of paradise inside the gates of The Preserve on the Galien. Schedule your private tour today & experience the luxury & tranquility that this home and this developer has brought to New Buffalo.

19 Preserve Way, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Elizabeth Roch (lizroch1@gmail.com) from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

$619,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 2,170 SqFt. 24006458 MLS
Welcome to your new sanctuary! This meticulously rebuilt 4 bdrm 2 bath home, nestled among majestic oaks in a serene neighborhood just minutes from Lake Michigan and New Buffalo Beach. Selling turn key furnished with short term rental permit in place to just renew. Check with township for further details. Completely reconstructed from the foundation up in 2020, this stunning residence offers the perfect blend of modern amenities and timeless charm. The heart of the home is the spacious open living area, featuring a cozy stone fireplace and beautiful hardwood floors, creating the perfect space for relaxing or hosting gatherings. The adjacent kitchen is a chef's dream, boasting sleek granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and ample cabinet space. With three well-appointed bedrooms on the main level, including a luxurious primary suite, this home offers versatility and comfort for families of all sizes. The 1st floor family/game room is a huge bonus along with the fourth bedroom that can accommodate additional guests or provide a dedicated workspace. Venture outside to discover your own private oasis, complete with a sprawling deck overlooking the expansive yard, perfect for summer gatherings and stargazing around the firepit. The attached two-car insulated garage provides ample storage space and convenience for all your recreational needs. Located in the coveted resort town of New Buffalo with close proximity to a myriad of recreational activities, from hiking and new biking trails coming this spring from Grand Beach to New Buffalo, to water sports and beachside relaxation. Whether you're seeking a weekend retreat or a full-time residence, this meticulously crafted home is sure to exceed your expectations. Don't miss out on the opportunity to make this your dream home - schedule your showing today and experience the epitome of coastal living!

13178 Fedde Avenue, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Taylor Lindstrom (lindstrom.taylor@gmail.com) from Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$3,500,000
7 Beds 8 Baths 5,524 SqFt. 24005628 MLS
Welcome to 51007 Lake Park Drive. Experience the tranquility, the breathtaking views, and the luxury that this Grand Beach gem has to offer. With more than 5500 sq feet of living, and 100' of lake frontage, this 7 bed, 5 full 3 half bath retreat provides spacious living and endless possibilities for your family and guests. As you step through the grand entrance, you'll be greeted by a view of Lake Michigan that sets the tone for the coastal living spaces that await. The main level features one of two primary suites, a lakefront living area perfect for hosting gatherings and enjoying breathtaking lake views, a fantastic open kitchen complete with ample counter space, a generous island, and a three-season sunroom perfect for watching the sunset over Lake Michigan. A standout feature of this lakeside estate are the beautiful outdoor areas overlooking the lake. Ideal for entertaining and relaxation, these spaces provide the perfect backdrop for sunset soirees and morning coffees alike. The lush backyard is a private oasis, with meticulously landscaped grounds leading to the sunset deck. For those seeking ultimate relaxation, the large inground pool is a refreshing haven on warm summer days. Lounge by the poolside and soak up the sun in style. This luxury lakefront home is not just a residence; it's a lifestyle. Embrace the opportunity to make this dream property your own and experience the finest in lakeside living. Don't miss out on the chance to call this extraordinary estate your forever home. Contact us today to schedule your private tour and see the magic of lakefront luxury for yourself! Your retreat by Lake Michigan awaits!

51007 Lake Park Drive, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Elizabeth Roch (lizroch1@gmail.com) from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

$2,445,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 3,554 SqFt. 24004857 MLS
Discover the epitome of modern luxury living on the enchanting Galien River peninsula in New Buffalo, Michigan - a hidden gem just a heartbeat away from the vibrant city life of Chicago. This stunning 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath estate offers breathtaking river views from every corner, creating an immersive experience that resonates with the dynamic spirit of discerning buyers. Enjoy this exclusive waterfront property from the meticulously crafted home that provides commanding views in all directions. The gourmet kitchen is a masterpiece, featuring custom cabinetry, granite counters, and top-of-the-line appliances from Subzero, Dacor, and Bosch - catering to the sophisticated tastes of the modern homeowner.Escape to the upper-level primary suite with its private balcony overlooking the river. The primary suite is complemented by a lavish ensuite bathroom boasting dual vanities, a soaking tub, and a walk-in shower. Three additional upper-level bedrooms and bathrooms ensure ample space for guests, while the main level fifth bedroom offers a private sun porch for moments of morning reflection or evening relaxation. Experience ultimate relaxation in the extraordinary top-level lookout, offering spectacular views of the protected nature preserve during the day and enchanting lighted harbor views in the evening. Multiple decks, patios, and a private floating boat dock, complete with a coveted 45 ft boat slip and lift, provide seamless access to the river for water activities. Just a short distance away, downtown New Buffalo and the beach beckon, creating a perfect blend of tranquility and accessibility. Whether seeking a year-round residence or a summer escape, this home promises the ultimate lifestyle. Immerse yourself in the essence of luxurious riverside living - schedule your tour today and make this extraordinary property your own.

202 E Water Street, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Elizabeth Roch (lizroch1@gmail.com) from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

Start Your Search

New Buffalo MI Homes For Sale & Real Estate

Looking for homes for sale in New Buffalo MI? Well our website features the best New Buffalo MI Real Estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. All of our homes for sale in New Buffalo MI are updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

If you're wanting a more specific search of homes for sale in New Buffalo  MI, you can use our Interactive Map Search which allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us to help you find homes for sale in New Buffalo MI today!