New Buffalo MI Homes For Sale

New Buffalo MI Homes For Sale

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,376 SqFt. 23135295 MLS
Welcome to your sanctuary in the heart of Downtown New Buffalo, where urban convenience meets rustic tranquility. This exceptional 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath gem was meticulously built in 2014 and offers the perfect blend of modern living and the serene feeling of seclusion. And you are just a short walk to a wide array culinary hotspots, shopping and world class beaches/Marinas. This home boasts a spacious and well-thought-out floor plan with the primary suite on the main floor complete with double closets for all your wardrobe needs. The open layout seamlessly connects the kitchen, family room, and dining areas, creating an inviting space for entertaining friends and family. The home also comes equipped with a large recreation/game room and workout area. Step outside onto the large rear deck, where you'll discover a firepit, perfect for warming up on cool fall nights or roasting marshmallows under the starry summer sky. And for golf enthusiast, you're in for a treat with your very own putting green, all set against a peaceful wooded backdrop. With an oversized one-car garage, you'll have plenty of space to store your outdoor equipment, golf cart, or SUV. Located just a short 70-mile drive from the vibrant city of Chicago, makes this the ideal weekend retreat for full-time residents or city dwellers seeking an escape. Don't miss out on this rare opportunity to own a slice of paradise in Downtown New Buffalo.

307 W Michigan Street, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Ryan D Green ( from Listing Office: Green Towne Coastal Realty.

5 Beds 2 Baths 2,439 SqFt. 23028696 MLS
Welcome to your perfect getaway, nestled in a charming golf cart friendly community with a golf course, basketball/tennis courts and parks for the kids. Private beach access, just a short 0.75 miles away! With 5 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, 2 living areas, and a 652 sq ft deck there's ample space for relaxation and enjoyment. The game room loft area make it an ideal retreat for groups of friends or families. Completely remodeled in 2021/2022 including hook up to city water, adding a full bathroom, all new flooring, paint, kitchen remodel, new lighting... check out the full list of updates available as well as the video walk through! Used as a successful short term rental and being sold TURN KEY Only a few minutes to downtown New Buffalo Nature lovers will be thrilled to know that Indiana Dunes National Park is only a short 20-minute drive from the house. And if you're feeling lucky, within a 10-minute radius, there are two different casinos. The home has been carefully designed for entertainment and relaxation. With two large living areas and a dining space seating 8, you and your guests can come together and create unforgettable memories. The big game room offers a plethora of fun activities, including foosball, ping pong, shuffleboard, pop-a-shot, magnetic dart board, as well as an assortment of board games and puzzles. Sleeping arrangements are no issue here, as the house comfortably accommodates up to 14 guests. Rest easy on three king beds, one queen bed, and four twin beds (two double bunks). Plus, there are two fold-down sofa beds available for extra comfort. Please note that the main beds can accommodate 12 guests, with the additional two guests utilizing the sofa beds in the second living area. In the kitchen, you'll find everything you need to whip up delicious meals, and the new appliances, including a dishwasher, ensure a hassle-free cooking experience. A washer and dryer are also available for guest use, making your stay all the more convenient. The outdoor space is equally inviting, with a spacious deck featuring patio seating for 8 and a BBQ grill ready for some delightful cookouts.

19727 Dogwood Drive, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Madyson Green ( from Listing Office: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Chicago.

2 Beds 2 Baths 2,598 SqFt. 23026247 MLS
Enjoy the changing of the seasons in this meticulously restored log cabin in a secluded serene setting. The property sits on over a half-acre, wooded lot, on a dead-end street with circular drive. Would make an amazing short-term rental or full time home. The cabin boasts two bedrooms and two bathrooms, with the potential to convert the loft overlooking the great room into either a bunk room or a master suite, offering versatility and additional living space. There is also a bonus room upstairs, which can serve various purposes according to the new owner's needs and preferences. Convenience and modernity meet history in this cabin, as it comes with a two-car attached garage and a main-floor primary bedroom. The presence of office, which can be converted into a third bedroom, adds to the functionality of the space. The property's infrastructure is well taken care of, with all mechanicals being new or newer, including the furnace, ductwork, humidifier, Ecobee Thermostat (2022), central air, water heater (2018), and steel garage door (2016). The dry cement crawlspace running the length of the home provides additional storage options. Given its unique features, this cabin would be an excellent choice both as a permanent residence and as a potential short-term rental property, capitalizing on its proximity to downtown New Buffalo's beach, shops, and restaurants. The location allows residents and guests to enjoy the amenities of the town while still reveling in the peace and beauty of the natural surroundings.

18711 Park View Drive, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Jennifer Wurster ( from Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

7 Beds 8 Baths 10,167 SqFt. 23016301 MLS
Experience Lake Michigan living in a most exquisite way. Combining luxurious living with breathtaking natural beauty nestled on the shores of Lake Michigan, this stunning estate boasts a custom built 4-bedroom main house and a separate 3-bedroom guest house, offering unparalleled comfort and privacy for you and your guests. Every inch of this immaculately appointed estate has been thoughtfully curated. Expertly designed and constructed to the highest standards of luxury and sophistication, this world-class home spans more than 10,000 square feet. The custom design and attention to detail are evident throughout, with high ceilings, elegant finishes, and an abundance of natural light that pours in through the large windows, providing dramatic views of the lake and exquisite sunsets. The main house boasts four generous bedrooms, each offering a private sanctuary for rest and rejuvenation, a full private gym, a lakeside office, and a two gorgeously appointed laundry rooms. The master suite is a true oasis, complete with a luxurious en-suite bathroom, and walk-in closet. Each room of this special home shines in the unparalleled Lake Michigan sunsets. The heart of the home is a chef's dream kitchen, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, a spacious center island, and ample counter and storage space. Whether you're preparing a casual meal or hosting a lavish dinner party, this kitchen will exceed your expectations. Adjacent to the kitchen is a sophisticated dining area, perfect for enjoying intimate meals with family and friends. The adjoining living room offers a cozy fireplace and comfortable seating, creating an inviting space to relax and unwind. The spacious office looks out to the lake, and is beautifully appointed with built-ins throughout. The outdoor space is equally impressive, with a custom-designed Boilini pool that serves as the centerpiece of the meticulously landscaped grounds. Dive into the refreshing waters or simply lounge poolside, enjoying the warm sun and gentle breezes. Entertain guests with ease hosting unforgettable gatherings against the backdrop of the tranquil lake. The guest house is a true gem, offering three well-appointed bedrooms, two wet-bars, two full baths, gaming area, and private laundry facilities. Your guests will relish in the privacy and comfort provided by this separate dwelling, creating a memorable and enjoyable experience for all. Sun Valley Falls offers more than just a home; it offers a lifestyle. Situated in the friendly Lake Michigan community of Grand Beach, just an hour outside of Chicago, this property provides an idyllic setting to embrace all that Lake Michigan living has to offer. Don't miss the opportunity to own this extraordinary estate, where luxury, comfort, and natural beauty converge. Contact us today to schedule a private viewing and experience the magic of Sun Valley Falls for yourself.

49106 Sun Valley Falls Boulevard, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Elizabeth Roch ( from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

5 Beds 5 Baths 3,554 SqFt. 23014397 MLS
Experience unparalleled luxury living on the Galien River peninsula in New Buffalo, Michigan. This exquisite 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath estate boasts captivating river views from nearly every room. Nestled on over four acres of private waterfront property, enjoy commanding views in all directions. Meticulously built to the highest standards, the home showcases a gourmet kitchen with custom cabinetry, granite counters, and premium appliances from Subzero, Dacor, and Bosch. The expansive upper-level master suite features a private balcony overlooking the river, as well as a luxurious ensuite bathroom with dual vanities, a soaking tub, and a walk-in shower. Three additional upper level bedrooms and three additional bathrooms provide plenty of space for guests. Main level fifth bedroom features its own private sun porch for morning reflection or an evening's relaxation. Relax and recharge in the extraordinary top-level look out, with spectacular views of the protected nature preserve during the day, and truly special lighted harbor views in the evening. Enjoy some outdoor time on one of the multiple decks and patios or the private floating boat dock, allowing for easy access to the river for water activities. Also included is coveted 45 ft boat slip with a lift. Downtown New Buffalo and beach are a short distance away. This home harmonizes the tranquility of a secluded estate with the convenience of being steps away from the marina and New Buffalo's attractions. Whether year-round or for summer escapes, this home promises the ultimate lifestyle. Schedule your tour today and seize the essence of luxurious riverside living.

202 E Water Street, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Elizabeth Roch ( from Listing Office: @properties Christie's International R.E..

5 Beds 5 Baths 3,150 SqFt. 23009459 MLS
The Best of both worlds is what you will find in this Michiana Michigan home. A perfectly preserved vintage cottage with gorgeous original knotty pine wood work throughout, soaring wood beamed ceiling and a two-story stone fireplace great you when entering the home. The front porch was converted to a four-season room, adding even more space to entertain family and friends. Both spaces are surrounded by additional windows and skylights making them bright and inviting. In the newer part of the home there is a large kitchen with high end appliances, large L shaped island for additional seating, abundant cabinetry for storage all open to the dining and additional living area. Bring the outside in on those beautiful days with sliding doors that surround this space, or bring the party out onto the back deck with fire pit area. Also on the main level is a newer primary ensuite bedroom, with sliding doors onto the back deck. The second-floor addition has four bedrooms with vaulted ceilings, all plus sized and with their own unique character like a second level balcony, attached bathroom or large alcove for an office space, kids bunk/crib area or a peaceful reading nook. In the full basement with separate outside entrance there is a bathroom and two separate shower rooms to wash away the sand from a day spent at the beach. Basement also has a rec room area for ping pong or pool table, a laundry area, workshop area and 6 additional walk-in storage areas. The beaches of Lake Michigan are one block away from this home. Hop in your golf cart or stroll the winding streets to the Newly designed Michiana Village park for the playground, bocce ball, tennis, pickle ball and basketball courts or the covered gazebo for a picnic. You will enjoy this neighborhood's charm and character and will love being so close to the lake whether this is your vacation home or full-time residence. Get ready to make memories here for years to come.

3983 Ponchartrain Drive, New Buffalo

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Line Mullins ( from Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

Start Your Search

New Buffalo MI Homes For Sale & Real Estate

Looking for homes for sale in New Buffalo MI? Well our website features the best New Buffalo MI Real Estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. All of our homes for sale in New Buffalo MI are updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

If you're wanting a more specific search of homes for sale in New Buffalo  MI, you can use our Interactive Map Search which allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us to help you find homes for sale in New Buffalo MI today!